I’m so sick of buying yogurt tubes for the kids. They are wasteful, full of sugar, and EXPENSIVE. I had a friend that started making yogurt in the Instant Pot, but it was full of sugar (a can of sweetened condensed milk to the tune of 22g of sugar). With a few tweaks, I was able to come out with a low carb, no added sugar, vanilla yogurt that the kids LOVED. Pair that with my re-fillable pouches, it was a match made in heaven!

Ingredients:

  • 52 oz high quality whole milk (I used Fairlife brand)
  • 2 Tbsp live culture yogurt (If you’ve made this yogurt previously, you can use it to make the next batch. If not, try Fage 5% greek yogurt.)
  • 4 Tbsp vanilla (based on taste)
  • 1/2 cup (based on taste) granular erythritol (based on taste)

Directions:

  1. Whisk all ingredients together in Instant Pot until existing yogurt is broken up and liquified.
  2. Close the lid to your instant pot and place valve on seal.
  3. Select the yogurt setting. This setting takes 8 hours to run.
  4. When Instant Pot is done, remove the lid and carefully scoop your yogurt into a strainer. I love my Bigger Better Nut Bag from Ellie’s Best. You can find one here: Ellie’s Best (and my link will get you 10% off when you use the code MNKetoMom!)
  5. Hang yogurt bag above the bowl to remove liquid. You don’t need to squeeze it just allow it to gently drain. I found hanging the bag from an upper cabinet handle works great.
  6. Discard liquid in bowl and empty yogurt into it. Cover and refrigerate for at least 8 hours.

From here, you can simply dish it from the stash and enjoy, or use refillable pouches for easy grab and go for the kids! We have used these for years. They unzip at the bottom for easy filling and cleaning and have lids for when on the go. I even freeze them (just don’t fill too full!), so they can travel longer with us.

Comments (7)

  1. Sandy Skalicky

    Reply

    I tried this recipe and after 8 hours mine was still liquid. I ended up dumping it. Did that ever happen to you? Any tips you have for me to try?

    • MNKetoMom

      Reply

      Hi Sandy!
      I’ve never had that problem, and I make it weekly.

      Couple questions:
      1-What milk did you use?
      2-Did the yogurt you used as starter have live cultures in it?

      Those would be my first two suspicions.

      • Sandy

        Reply

        I used the same milk as you but used YQ yogurt. It says it has cultures but not specifically live active cumtures. I’m not sure if that is different. It’s the whole thing is liquid. Nothing is solid. Do you feel the outside of your instant pot gets really hot when the yogurt is being made because mine barely feels warm. I hope there isn’t something wrong with my instant pot. I just got it for Christmas. 🙁

        • MNKetoMom

          Reply

          Not sure if the yogurt was a problem 🤔 I have never felt the outside of the pot because I usually run it when we are off doing other things 🙈 hopefully that’s not the issue.

    • MNKetoMom

      Reply

      Also-There will still be liquid on the top of it. When you careful spoon it into the Ellie’s Best bag, you will drain that liquid out. Should just be watery liquid sitting on the top of it though.

  2. Kelly

    Reply

    I’m curious — how do you calculate the macros/nutritional info on this? Do you just use the milk nutritional info and divide by # servings? Your liquid your straining out — is that the lactose? If so with it would be some of the naturally occurring sugar?

    • MNKetoMom

      Reply

      Hey Kelly-
      I calculated it using all the ingredients and dividing by the servings. You don’t have to strain the liquid if you like a thinner yogurt, but I prefer a thicker texture. As far as the lactose- I use lactose free milk, so not sure on that.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *